tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1080140850363406128.post7695015032044705843..comments2024-01-22T15:10:10.948+00:00Comments on Modesty Blase: Modesty Blasehttp://www.blogger.com/profile/07239895264144025670noreply@blogger.comBlogger4125tag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1080140850363406128.post-70939185784824885182023-09-04T06:06:32.451+01:002023-09-04T06:06:32.451+01:00https://saglamproxy.com
metin2 proxy
proxy satın a...<a href="https://saglamproxy.com/" rel="nofollow">https://saglamproxy.com</a><br /><a href="https://saglamproxy.com/metin-2-proxy-satin-al/" title="metin2 proxy" rel="nofollow">metin2 proxy</a><br /><a href="https://saglamproxy.com/ipv4-residential-proxy-satin-al/" title="proxy satın al" rel="nofollow">proxy satın al</a><br /><a href="https://saglamproxy.com/knight-online-proxy-satin-al/" title="knight online proxy" rel="nofollow">knight online proxy</a><br /><a href="https://saglamproxy.com/4g-mobil-proxy-satin-al/" title="mobil proxy satın al" rel="nofollow">mobil proxy satın al</a><br />JS4Zdefnenoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1080140850363406128.post-82525574686026362402010-08-15T02:41:37.840+01:002010-08-15T02:41:37.840+01:00I think is what you're saying is that there...I think is what you're saying is that there's a cultural Judaism with no link to the spiritual (i.e. to God). To that I could easily agree, many people out there identify with smoked salmon but not shabbat, and to them being Jewish might be a very occasional infringement on life.<br /><br />This isn't at all a reason to change how we go about conversion. While people differ hugely in religious observance the laws themselves don't change. If nobody kept Shabbat we wouldn't suddenly be exempt from keeping it. By that logic we can't convert somebody who likes the idea of a seder but hates the idea of kashrut simply because Jews out there identify with that notion. I don't think it is a flaw to conclude this.<br /><br />When somebody converts, they not only become a part of our people all the baggage we come with. Most significantly, they sign on the dotted line to the contract of Jewish Law set out by God (and fiddled by rabbis). This doesn't mean that it's suddenly OK for the gates to Judaism to be dictated by a love of sarcasm, guilt and chicken soup but not agreeing to give up working on Saturday and wearing that lovely wool and linen jacket. <br />Society and culture change but we keep by the same values as always. A conversion can be annulled in some cases of the convert clearly having not accepted Jewish observance. Would a 'cultural conversion' have to be reversed if we found out they actually got on pretty well with the mother in law and didn't like chopped herring?Zack Pyzernoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1080140850363406128.post-28913673422698711502010-08-11T23:48:22.055+01:002010-08-11T23:48:22.055+01:00Thanks Zack for your thoughtful post. I know my id...Thanks Zack for your thoughtful post. I know my ideas are fairly impractical - I was merely trying to put something out there that could be discussed. I think perhaps your flaw is to assume that there is no sociological lifestyle dimension to Judaism that is somewhat devoid of spiritual content. Does it make Judaism less worty?Modesty Blasehttp://www.modestyblase.co.uknoreply@blogger.comtag:blogger.com,1999:blog-1080140850363406128.post-66737687691979802682010-08-10T02:34:39.620+01:002010-08-10T02:34:39.620+01:00Not to discredit the threat of intermarriage, it&#...Not to discredit the threat of intermarriage, it's the greatest internal threat we face, but I think your ideas are a little flawed. We've never been a proselytizing people. Look at Christianity and Islam, not only spread by a sword but by selling a religion to save non believers. We're neither of those people, and to reduce Judaism to something which can be bought into with anything less than total devotion is self defeating. Converts are vital to Judaism because of their passion and commitment, not because they're numerous. <br />What happens when there are too many men after we put the advert in the Times for men to apply at their local shul? More women this time? I'm no economist but Judaism should stay outside the realms of supply and demand. We're a religion, not a commodity, and our dignified position on conversion shouldn't change, along with any of out values, unless completely, utterly necessary.Zack Pyzernoreply@blogger.com